The stay of the Meskhetians in KK is significantly aggravated by the fact
that in practice they are completely deprived of the state social support —
pensions, allowances and compensations.
From 1989 the pensioners whose stay in the Territory was not registered
have been denied to have their Uzbekistan pensions either re-registered
or calculated. The unregistered refugees were also disallowed other social
payments and allowances. The War veterans without residence registration
are bereaved of the warranted 50 per cent discount for using utilities
(electricity, water and gas).
At first the officials who refused to meet the refugees requests for pensions
and allowances referred only to the decisions of Territory Administration,
such as the Instruction of the Territory Social Security Department to
regional and town departments no.14-01 of 17.03.91: «... The procedure
for the recovery of pensions envisaged by letter of the RSFSR Ministry
of Social Security no.1-12-È of 06.02.90 shall cover persons who were compelled
to leave the places of their permanent residency. At present time the migrants
continue to arrive to the Territory. Therefore we recommend that pension
files requests be subject to prior residence registration in the Territory...
Upon the receipt of responses to earlier pension files requests for the
pensioners who are not registered in the Territory their files should be
returned to the regional social security department that forwarded the
request with the recommendation to transfer pensions by remittance to the
place of actual domicile in our Territory. For the migrants who do not
have permit to stay in the Territory pensions should not be allowed in
the way some departments did... » [the document is available at the authors
of the report].
The instructions from Krasnodar were replicated by regional and town authorities.1
In October of 1992 the Ministry of Social Security of Russia issued «Instruction»
no.1-91-Ó «On Providing Pensions and Allowances to Persons Arriving to
the Russian Federation from the Republics of the Former USSR» which officially
confirmed that social payments depended on the availability of residence
registration or the official status of a refugee or a forced migrant.
In connection with the problem of effecting social payments to the Turks–Meskhetians
migrated to Russia Deputy RF Social Security Minister A.Klimkina has provided
the following explanation in the letter addressed to the RF President Assistant
D.Ryurikov: «...According to the Federal Migration Service of Russia the
Turks–Meskhetians shall be forced migrants but at the same time this category
of citizens does not qualify for the current normative documents on refugees
and forced migrants. The Turks–Meskhetians are leaving the places authorised
for their settlement and moving on their own into the southern areas of
the Russian Federation where they are denied permits to stay (Stavropol,
Krasnodar Territories, Rostov Region) and consequently are deprived of
the opportunity to exercise the right for pensions, social allowances.
We think it necessary that the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian
Federation consider the problem of temporary residence registration of
the Meskhetian Turks in the communities where they presently residing in
Russia » [no.1-3565-9 of 24.11.92 ].
All the appeals to the authorities concerning the payment of pensions to
the pensioners without residence registration had negative responses. According
to Yazdan Gafurov, an activist of the Umid Society, the Turks–Meskhetians —
the War veterans residing in Krymsk region secured a petition from the
Defence Ministry, but the regional social security department refused to
calculate their pensions [27.10.94.]
Some refugees who had pensions in Uzbekistan before 1989 and who had not
annulled their residency registration there succeeded in their attempts
to have the pensions remitted to the places of their actual domicile. However
this practice was halted after 1991. Some pensioners who had obtained permanent
residence registration in other Russian regions ensured that their pensions
would be remitted to the new places of their residency and be paid by the
power of attorney. Consequently, they had to travel to the communities
where had been registered previously to get this money. Some pensioners
travelled personally to Uzbekistan for their pensions until travel expenses
started to exceed the amount of their pensions.
Registered pensioners as well as those who obtained temporary residence
permits with the help of Territory Administration late in 1994 — in 1995
have their pension files processed or have it being done now in the Territory.
Many people we talked to emphasised that they were shocked most of all
by the moral aspect of the situation rather than by the material damage:
some 40–45 years of labouring on cotton plantations appeared to have no
reward; the state had threw away as useless those people who had fought
for it and worked for it for decades. Here are the statements of the veterans.
Abdulla Akhmedov is Merited Teacher of Uzbekistan, an invalid of the Patriotic
War, has 20 governmental awards, participated in the battles for the liberation
of Krasnodar Territory: «We have been living here for six years, applied
for the status, for the permit to stay, for political rights, for the privatisation
cheque — everything was denied. The invalids of war — without a hand, without
a leg — are not paid pensions, they are old, many of them are crippled,
they worked for 45 years at the collective farms and the state farms in
the heat of 50 centigrade, in the production sector — yet they are not paid
pensions. Now people are searching for those who died all over Russia,
to make monuments to them, but they are unable to support those who survived.
When I fought with the Kuban Cavalry Corps under the command of Dovator
we had amiable relations with each other, and now our children are frightened:
»Grandpa, when the Cossacks are going to drive us away?" Sarval Chakhalidze,
an invalid of the Patriotic War, has 7 military awards: «After Fergana
events I came here purposely, — because I participated in the Kuban region
liberation, but I found myself deprived here. For 6 years they have been
refusing to grant a residence permit, to legalise my house: we are suspended
between sky and earth. When the 50th Anniversary of the Victory was celebrated
nobody invited us nowhere, we are just forgotten, that’s all».
SOCIAL SECURITY