The children of the refugees without residence registration are admitted
to high schools unhindered. After graduation they are entitled to enter
vocational training schools but the access to state trade high schools
or higher educational institutes is blocked for them because they don’t
have residence registration.
The problems connected with high school education can hardly be discussed
within the categories of the rights abridgement or violation. There were
exceptional cases in 1990–1991 as some people told us when high school
graduates were not given their high school certificates. Unfortunately,
we could not double check this information and find out what was the reason
for the refusal.
The Turkish children experienced the most the serious problems in high
schools in 1989–1991 in connection with a poor knowledge of the Russian
language. The situation in many schools tends to be as follows: the Slavic
children form forms «A» and «B» while the children of the Turks–Meskhetians,
Armenians, Yezidians , Kurds are concentrated in individual classes including
the so called «correctional classes» (forms for children who permanently
lag behind in the educational process). The representatives of school administrations
and regional departments of people’s education believe that this approach
makes it easier for the teachers to work and facilitates the children’s
adaptation to the barely familiar language environment.
It also should be noted that many children find it hard to go to school
because of the necessity to financially assist their families and to work
in the fields and because of inadequate housing conditions. The scores
of the Turkish schoolchildren have to quit school for the sake of work.
In Krymsk school no.2 more than 100 children of 750 students are the Turks,
Armenians and Yezidians. According to school director F.F.Kormishin the
only problem is still the problem of the tongue barrier as many children
have a poor knowledge of the Russian language. In co-ordination with the
regional department of people’s education they have formed correctional
classes for the children with a poorer knowledge of the language. Unlike
usual forms where some 30 children are studying these classes have 18 children.
(There are totally six classes of this type: forms from 1 through 4 and
two fifth forms.) The Turkish parents would want their children to learn
together with the Russians so they could master the language as soon as
possible. There are no special problems with the Turkish children as far
as discipline is concerned, no ethnical confrontations were noticed either.
All children are catered irrespective of their residence registration within
the same financial limits. The parents committee has Turkish members. As
of now the school is heavily overpopulated — it has 30 complements, that
is 1.5 times as many as prescribed.
4 of 10 first forms in the school of Nizhnebakanskiy stl. in Krymsk Region
are «Turkish» and being taught by the Turkic teachers. Overpopulation in
Nizhnebakanskiy school is extremely huge — 60 complements.
In Kholmskiy (Abinsk Region) the Turkish schoolchildren of the 1st through
the 3rd forms are brought together and have a Turkic teacher. Correctional
groups for the students of the 5th–7th forms whose Russian is poor were
organised even three years ago. Kholmskiy is inhabited basically with the
Turks–Meskhetians who arrived from Namangan where few Russians lived and
where they had to send their children to Uzbek schools, therefore the problem
of poor knowledge of the Russian language is especially acute here. The
things look easier in Akhtyrskiy stl. and in Abinsk — the majority of the
Turkish families who reside there have arrived from Tashkent Oblast.
Thus, despite the above marked difficulties the high schools of Krasnodar
Territory make their best to have the children of the refugees involved
in the process of training. However, we have hard time to give an ultimate
answer as to what degree the «Slavic» and «non-Slavic» division is justified
in each particular case and whether it would not hinder the children of
the refugees, in particular the Turks–Meskhetians, from achieving an adequate
education level. We got the impression that in general teachers displayed
tolerance, interest and creative initiative and that it found support on
the part of the Territory people’s education authorities.
The refugees are not entitled to enter state higher educational institutes
because they do not have passports or residence permits. Those who have
residence registration may become students at higher educational institutes,
for example, according to B.Iskenderov at the present time there are seven
Turkish–Meskhetian students in Apsheronsk Region. As Nizhnebakanskiy settlement
administration chief T.A.Shaprynskaya said some high school graduates became
students at private higher educational institutes.
Education is one of the most painful problems for the Meskhetian leaders
and activists. They are anxious that the number of the Turks–Meskhetians
with special vocational and higher education has decreased by scores of
times during the last years. The process of intelligentsia formation was
practically suspended and, to their opinions, it is equivalent to the near-term
decrease of the total intellectual level of the Meskhetians, the conversion
of this people into unskilled workers.
EDUCATION